What 明命|MING does not compute
This page lists the classical ideas 明命|MING’s engine leaves out, or works out but does not let decide anything. Each one comes with its reason.
Most sources never say what they leave out. 明命|MING keeps a written list, and this page is that list in plain words. Its rule is simple: if an idea is missing from the engine and missing from the list, the list is wrong.
Why publish silences at all
Because a silent omission cannot be argued with, and a stated one can. The category has a long habit of concepts accreting — every school’s extra star, every almanac’s extra rule — until a chart can be made to mean anything. The guard against that drift is not to compute less; it is to say, for each concept, what it is allowed to do.
The registry sorts its silences into four kinds, and this page keeps the same four: things shown but never reasoned from; things computed but leashed; things not computed yet, with what would have to be true first; and things excluded, with the reason.
Shown, never reasoned from
Two families sit on the chart as reference and are never consulted by the reasoning. 纳音 — the poetic names the sixty pairs carry, “roadside earth”, “hairpin gold” — are displayed for every pillar and never enter the judgement of structure, strength or need; they are the readiest handle for a reading to drift on, which is exactly why they are held out. Two bounded uses are on the record: a colour formula in the daily reading uses pillar 纳音, because it was the formula that fit the measured data — an 89% match — and two symbolic stars, 学士 and 词馆, are read from the year pillar’s 纳音, on the same leash as every star. Neither feeds back into a verdict about the chart. 胎元 and 命宫, the conception and life palaces, are reference only if ever shown, with no reasoning and no timing power.
The twelve-star year line (太岁十二神). The Yearly Insights, the year report, also prints the older almanac table — 太岁, 太阳, 丧门 and the rest, found by the distance between your year branch and the year’s — as a quotation, with the tradition’s own 吉 or 凶 and its customs inside the quotation marks. It is shown as tradition and never reasoned from: 明命|MING’s own reading of a year uses the five relations on your Chinese zodiac year, and takes from the old line the behaviour, not the custom.
pillar 纳音 旬 空亡 year 庚午 路旁土 roadside earth 甲子 戌亥 month 壬午 杨柳木 willow wood 甲戌 申酉 day 辛亥 钗钏金 hairpin gold 甲辰 寅卯 hour 乙未 沙中金 sand gold 甲午 辰巳 computed · displayed · never reasoned from
Computed, kept on a leash
The symbolic stars (神煞). Forty-two stars are computed for every chart, from forty-five rule entries. They are auxiliary and descriptive: visible behind the “why” of a reading, never allowed to override the structure or the elements the chart needs. They are vivid, which is precisely why the leash exists — a vivid star given the last word is the commonest way a reading stops being a reading. For the chart the other pages use, ten of them fire — 天乙贵人, 华盖, 将星, 劫煞, 孤鸾煞 among them — and not one of the ten moves the verdict on strength, structure or need by a hair.
空亡 (旬空). Computed as a marker, displayed, and forbidden to do the thing it is most often used for: it never cancels a root, and never flips a verdict of strength or structure. A storehouse is not an emptiness, and an emptiness is not an absence — the tests for strength and for special structures do not see it. Strong or weak is judged on what is actually there.
羊刃, twice. The blade appears both as a star and as a structure type, on different layers of the reading — and both are legitimate. The two are kept apart rather than merged, so that a marker never gets promoted into a structure by accident. For a yin Day Master the two layers point at different branches — the structure takes the month that holds its Rob Wealth, the star sits on the branch after its 禄 — so a reader can see both, on different branches, each by its own rule.
The twelve life-stages (十二长生). Computed, and used in one place: the Yearly Insights opens each year with the stage your Day Master stands at in that year’s branch, in plain words — sprouting, full strength, storing up — as the year’s one-line reading. It is never a verdict on your natal chart: rootedness — whether the Day Master has ground under it — carries what matters there, and the doctrine is set that the stages are secondary and never overturn the primary structure. The natal “seat” row was removed from My Nature for that reason.
Your relatives (六亲). The four pillars are named as areas of life — family roots and elders; work, parents and siblings; yourself, your partner and home; children and the results of your work — in the app and in the Yearly Insights, and the Yearly Insights (and Ask 明命) may also say which star stands for the spouse, by gender, as an area to tend. What is not done, by decision: a prediction about a relative, a marriage timing, or a verdict on the partner — a reading is of the person holding it.
Not computed yet — and what would have to be true first
These are positions, not a roadmap. Each names the condition that would have to hold before the concept was computed; none of them is promised.
True solar time and birthplace. The clock-time basis is locked and stated — the Singapore and Malaysia frame assumed, births near a boundary flagged. An opt-in precise mode would need to exist before the correction did; Is BaZi accurate? names the convention.
Compatibility (合婚). Nothing is built, deliberately; there is no second chart in the product to match against. Hour-level timing (流时). Out, until a real use case exists — the day is the finest grain the reading speaks at.
Excluded, with the reason
Childhood luck (小运 / 童限运). The schools genuinely contradict each other on the method — one starts from the hour pillar, another from a fixed pillar set by sex — and a method that cannot be stated cleanly should not be run quietly. The years before the first decade are shown as a state, not scored.
Virtual characters (拱夹 · 暗合 · 暗冲). Characters implied but not present in the chart invite reading things into it; nothing in structure, need or strength consumes them. One timing surface does, narrowly: the Yearly Insights counts a year stem that combines away a hidden favourable one, at half weight, and names it — the only place they speak. Contested combinations (争合 · 妒合) carry no meaning on their own — they are consulted only as a blocker on one special-structure test. Two-force and follow-the-qi structures (两神成象 · 从气) are detected but reach the reading only as a fallback, never as a confident verdict.
A third verdict from the five roles (仇神 · 闲神). The five roles are named — the Yearly Insights, the year report, prints the row — but two states, with you and against you, carry every decision: the bystander reads with you, the 仇神 — the element that attacks the needed one — reads against; what your chart actually needs states the position. Splitting a decade five-and-five between its stem and branch: the pair is read as one, with any half-cycle emphasis kept secondary.
Timing power for reference concepts. The life palace, the conception palace, 空亡 entering a decade, 纳音 clashes across years — none of these is given any say over timing; reference stays reference. Direction stars (三煞 and the yearly directional taboos) belong to 风水, the reading of place, not to the reading of a chart. The Yearly Insights does carry the year’s flying stars as a separate page about the home — place-based, with its 太岁, 岁破 and 三煞 sectors, no input from your pillars and no say in your reading. Almanac-grade stars: one whose own rule admits it is non-canonical (天财) is cut; two others (金匱 · 龙德) were cut in the first census and admitted back on a later review, at low confidence and labelled for what they are — kept on the record rather than half-kept in silence.
The old rules for women’s charts (古法女命). Rejected on value grounds, not technical ones: those frames read the same character as ambition in one chart and misfortune in another because of who is holding it. Here gender changes two computational inputs — the direction the decades run, and which star the Yearly Insights reads as the spouse — and nothing about what any symbol is allowed to mean.
The rule behind the ledger — and its corrections
The registry’s standing rule is the one this page opened with: if a concept is absent from the engine and absent from the registry, that is a bug in the registry. Silences are published, not slipped.
It also keeps a corrections log, which is the part worth trusting. An early review claimed 空亡 was “absent entirely”; it was not — it was computed under its other name, 旬空, and the leash had to be written down properly. The claim that no census of the symbolic stars existed was wrong too. The registry records that it was wrong, and what the correction was. A ledger of silences that never had to correct itself would be the one to doubt.
What this page is not saying
Not that these concepts are worthless. Several are real, old, and used seriously by real schools. These are statements about what this engine lets decide — positions, not verdicts on the tradition.
Not a promise of features. The “not yet” rows name a condition, not a date. Nothing on this page is coming soon.
Not the refusals you meet as a reader. Those — no event prediction, no verdict on a date, no matching, no remedies — are stated where they apply: on the reading surfaces, and on each page here that touches them. This page is the engine’s side of the same honesty.
Not “明命|MING computes less”. It computes the stars, the markers and the poetic names for every chart. What it refuses is to let them decide.
Where to go from here
The three judgements the leashes protect are the three pages that explain them: strength, the ten relations, and what the chart needs. Or open the “why” on any line of your own reading — the leashed stars are there, describing, and never once deciding.
Common questions
- Does 明命|MING use the symbolic stars (神煞)?
- It computes them — forty-two stars, from forty-five rule entries — and shows them behind the 'why' of a reading. It never lets one override the structure or the elements the chart needs. In the Yearly Insights a month’s stars add a small, capped weight to that month’s score — at most half a point. They describe; they do not decide your chart.
- Does it use 空亡 or 纳音?
- Both are computed and shown for every pillar, and neither is allowed to argue. 空亡 is a marker that never cancels a root or flips a verdict; 纳音 never enters the reasoning about structure, strength or need. Two bounded uses — a colour formula in the daily reading, and two leashed stars (学士 and 词馆) read from the year pillar's 纳音 — never feed back into any verdict about the chart.
- Why is there no 小运 — the childhood luck before the first decade?
- Because the schools contradict each other on how to compute it, and a method that cannot be stated cleanly should not be run quietly. The years before your first decade pillar are shown as a state, not scored.
- Does it compute the twelve life-stages, or compatibility?
- The twelve life-stages are computed and used in one place. The Yearly Insights opens each year with the stage your Day Master stands at in that year’s branch, in plain words. It is never a verdict on your natal chart, and never allowed to overturn its structure or what it needs. Compatibility is not computed at all: there is no second chart in the product, by design.